Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA) or administration?
When a company is struggling to keep up with paying its liabilities, creditor pressure can lead directors to pursue formal insolvency procedures. Two common choices for directors who wish to continue with their business include Company Voluntary Arrangements (CVAs) and administration. Whether a CVA or administration is the most suitable option for your company will likely depend on its financial resources and the business’ viability in its current structure.
Company Voluntary Arrangements
One of the most popular insolvency arrangements, a Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA) is a formal debt repayment scheme, combining all its unsecured debts into one compounded monthly sum. All interest and creditor pressure freeze for arrangement’s duration; often five years. Once the arrangement concludes, all remaining debt is written off.
More information about Company Voluntary ArrangementsAdministration
Administration is an insolvency process that protects companies from creditor action. It allows time to decide the best course of action for the company, be that selling it and its assets or producing a restructuring plan.
More information on administration
CVAs or Administration, how do they work?
CVAs consolidate all your company’s unsecured debts into one monthly outgoing tailored to what you can afford. Interest on debts is frozen for the arrangement’s duration, and any creditor pressure alleviated. The arrangement usually lasts five years, and after the final payment, any remaining unsecured debt is written off.
Administration is also a formal insolvency process. It involves a licensed insolvency practitioner (IP) taking control of the company, making the necessary changes to remove elements that have become unprofitable. One of the main goals of administration is to achieve better results for the creditors than if the company were to be wound up. While in control, the IP may choose to restructure the business or get it into a position where it could be sold. Creditor pressure ceases for the administration’s duration.
When do they work best?
Applying for a CVA would be more suitable for when the company’s core business is viable, but its debts risk pushing it into insolvency. The process allows the company to continue trading while repaying its debts, without the need for major restructuring. The process offers the company a sense of continuity while allowing time to pay off or reduce its debts. CVAs can also be useful if the insolvent company can’t meet the costs of an administration or the funds to buy back the assets in a pre-pack. CVAs also work if you wish to nullify some burdensome company contracts but keep the more beneficial ones.
How to apply for a CVAAdministration may be a more practical solution if the company doesn’t have the funds to repay its debts, company assets are at risk, or if creditors have rejected a proposed CVA. They may act as a feasible backup plan if a CVA fails, or more substantial restructuring is needed outside of repaying the debts.
We’d recommend administration where there is evidence that: the company can be rescued as a going concern, the process would achieve better results than if the company were wound up, or property and assets can be realised to distribute to secured or preferential creditors.
How to put your company into administrationIn summary
Both Company Voluntary Arrangements (CVAs) and administrations are formal insolvency arrangements for limited companies struggling from high levels of debt and creditor pressure.
A CVA will be appropriate if a company would be viable if not for its financial issues, which it could recover from if given time and guidance.
If a CVA won’t rectify the underlying financial issues, administration is an alternative which protects against creditor action. Undergoing administration relieves the creditor pressure and allows us to look at restructuring the company, removing the unprofitable elements, and allowing some breathing space while deciding the next course of action.
How we can help
If your company is struggling with intense creditor pressure and severe debts, speak to us before the situation becomes unmanageable. We can assess the company’s current situation and structure to decide which route out of insolvency is right for your business. All initial consultations are free of charge and obligation, and our friendly advisors are on hand to offer regulated, impartial advice.
Case Studies
ET Rowlands & Sons
Kelly Burton • Automotive • Administration
Assets from the well-known Telford road haulage contractor ET Rowlands & Sons, which has closed after nearly 60 years in business, are to be sold by auction online.
The firm, known for its striking red livery on its vehicles, provided road transport solutions for UK and continental Europe and operated a modern mixed fleet of rigid vehicles, tractor units and trailers.
Last week’s closure of the company, set up in 1958 by 87-year-old current director Mary Rowland’s father, saw all 28 jobs made redundant after the company lost a major contract and potential hopes for a pre-pack sale were dashed.
Kelly Burton and Lisa Hogg from Yorkshire-based insolvency specialists Wilson Field were appointed joint administrators of ET Rowlands and Sons on 13 June at a meeting of members and creditors.
Wilson Field, have instructed valuers and asset management consultants Charterfields to dispose of the assets of the company, which operated a warehouse facility in Telford.
Vehicles and other items up for sale includes a fleet of 14 tractor units, seven rigid and flat HGVs by Scania, DAF and MAN, 14 curtainside and three flat back trailers, personalised numberplates including P7 ETR, P12 ETR, R4 ETR, S7 ETR, T2 ETR, V2 ETR, and 6 ETR, plant and office furniture. Other vehicles include a Vauxhall Movano 3.5T Dropside and Ford Transit T350 Panel Van.
Kelly Burton, director and insolvency practitioner at Wilson Field, said: “ET Rowlands & Sons was a well-established family run business that experienced loss of a major contract.
“The director came to Wilson Field for advice but regrettably the company entered administration and has been closed. As a consequence all 28 jobs have been lost. It is always sad to see a long-standing company go out of business with the loss of jobs.”
The online auction is now open and closes Tuesday July 4 from 12 noon. For further details visit www.charterfields.com
JS Security
Kelly Burton • Other • Administration
All 42 jobs have been saved at a Cheltenham security firm after it was bought out of administration.
Joint administrators Kelly Burton and Lisa Hogg of insolvency and business turnaround specialist Wilson Field were appointed to JS Security on 10 February after HMRC threatened to wind-up the company because of accumulated tax arrears.
The company, which operated from Old Station Drive in Cheltenham, has now been bought out of administration by existing, and associated company, JS Facilities Group Limited of Cheltenham, saving all 42 jobs.
The business will be operated by the existing management team lead by managing director John Search. The total value of the deal is undisclosed but it includes the business and the assets of the Cheltenham based company.
Kelly Burton, director and insolvency practitioner at Wilson Field, which has bases in Leeds and Sheffield, said;
“Unfortunately, the security services sector is very competitive which leads to hourly rate discounting and small margins.
“JS Security accumulated tax arrears which threatened its existence. After discussing the situation with the director, I am pleased that we have found a solution which will see the business continue to trade and also all 42 employees’ jobs transferred to the new company.”
JS Security was appointed the official security provider at Gloucester Rugby in June 2013 for two-years and also won the contract to provide matchday security for the four Rugby World Cup matches at Kingsholm Stadium in September 2015.
The contracts covered match day security, including the hospitality areas, car park security and any additional security requirements.
JS Facilities Group Limited has been running for 15 years and operates throughout Gloucestershire specialising in security services for sectors including commercial, logistics security, construction, events, key holding and alarm response.
Services include remote video monitoring, control room services, lone working monitoring, security guarding, door supervisors, mobile security patrols, event security and first aid training.
Aristocrat Pet Supplies
Kelly Burton • Retail • Administration
The business and assets belonging to a Sheffield online pet supplies company are up for sale. Aristocrat Pet Supplies, a family owned and run business, milled its own feed and seed on-site in Sheffield and has been trading for over 25 years selling agricultural raw materials, livestock, textile raw materials and semi-finished goods.
Sheffield-based insolvency specialists Wilson Field were called into the firm after it experienced increasing pressure and competition online. Andy Wood and Lisa Hogg were appointed as joint administrators for the company on January 26.
Wilson Field is trading the business in the short term with a view to finding a potential buyer for the company based on Holbrook Green Industrial Estate near Sheffield.
Andy Wood, associate director and insolvency practitioner at Wilson Field said:
“The business has encountered increased competition in recent years, principally from discount stores which have reduced margins.
“It has been on the market for several months but has not attracted any significant interest so far. As administrators, Wilson Field is trading the business in the short term to maximise realisations on a reduced staff base of seven.”
Aristocrat, which employed 19 staff, offered a range of pet supplies including dog and cat treats, chews, small animal bedding, wild bird supplies, poultry and aquatic food.
Free Consultation
Request a free confidential telephone consultation from 9am - 8pm, 7 days a week.
